Difference between revisions of "Practitioner's Tool / Sewers Comparison"
From Akvopedia
| (3 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 12: | Line 12: | ||
[[File:Sewerpic.png|100px|link=Sewers for Buildings]]<br/> | [[File:Sewerpic.png|100px|link=Sewers for Buildings]]<br/> | ||
| − | [[Sewers for Buildings|Sewers for Buildings]] | + | [[Practitioner's Tool / Sewers for Buildings|Sewers for Buildings]] |
| To transport wastewater from buildings to the treatment system<br/> | | To transport wastewater from buildings to the treatment system<br/> | ||
| Line 25: | Line 25: | ||
| style="text-align: center; vertical-align: middle" | | | style="text-align: center; vertical-align: middle" | | ||
[[File:Primtreatpic.png|100px|link=Settled Sewers]]<br/> | [[File:Primtreatpic.png|100px|link=Settled Sewers]]<br/> | ||
| − | [[ | + | [[Practitioner's Tool / Settled Sewers|Settled Sewers]] |
|Small to moderately-sized communities. Uses smaller pipes and can accommodate variable flows<br/> | |Small to moderately-sized communities. Uses smaller pipes and can accommodate variable flows<br/> | ||
| Moderate for the sewer pipes<br/> | | Moderate for the sewer pipes<br/> | ||
| Line 43: | Line 43: | ||
| style="text-align: center; vertical-align: middle" | | | style="text-align: center; vertical-align: middle" | | ||
[[File:Combined wet.jpg|100px|link=Combined Sewers]]<br/> | [[File:Combined wet.jpg|100px|link=Combined Sewers]]<br/> | ||
| − | [[ | + | [[Practitioner's Tool / Combined Sewers|Combined Sewers]] |
| Larger communities<br/> | | Larger communities<br/> | ||
| Moderate – groundwater, poor soils and variable slopes increase costs<br/> | | Moderate – groundwater, poor soils and variable slopes increase costs<br/> | ||
Latest revision as of 22:35, 22 November 2016
| Sewers |
Appropriate Use |
Relative Cost |
Operations and Maintenance |
Effectiveness |
|
|
To transport wastewater from buildings to the treatment system |
Generally low but can increase based on length of pipes, soils, and topography. Cost can be minimized by placing treatment as close to buildings as possible |
Low for gravity sewers Moderate for pressurized systems |
High - Effective when designed and installed properly |
| Small to moderately-sized communities. Uses smaller pipes and can accommodate variable flows |
Moderate for the sewer pipes High when considering the cost of septic or settling tanks at each building. |
Low for the sewers High for the septic tanks when considering the required desludging. |
High when community programs for desludging are provided | |
| Small to medium-sized communities |
Low - Allows sharing of sewer laterals, which reduces cost |
Low when communities are responsible for maintaining their own laterals, as they are more careful to operate properly |
High when strong community participation and bottom-up planning is provided | |
| Larger communities |
Moderate – groundwater, poor soils and variable slopes increase costs |
Low - Periodic declogging is generally required |
Moderate – Generally effective at moving waste away from population centers | |
| When variable slopes or distances will not allow gravity systems |
High - Pump tanks, pump equipment, and the cost of electricity adds to cost |
Moderate - Pump systems are generally reliable, but trash traps and screens often require continuous maintenance |
High - When installed and operated properly |
